Wall 1
Billy Wall
Systems Engineering II
Ms. Green
17 September 2015
Alternate Solutions Matrix
The houseboat design which best solves the background problem while following the specifications and limitations. Essentially, the ideal houseboat will be aesthetically pleasing to the client, have ample deck space, copious large windows, a lot of living space, and be a fun and relaxing place for anyone to stay. The houseboat is meant to alleviate stress from the client living in the city. Because of this objective, the houseboat must be enjoyable for a person to live on so that is a big factor while choosing a design.
The matrix allows for the designer to find out which solutions are most viable in all scenarios for the problem at hand. In the matrix, there are multiple categories that each alternate solution design is judged according to. A score is given to each alternate solution and the resulting total scores retrieved from each alternate solution will reveal the most superior design. Since this project is the house portion of a houseboat, the categories of the matrix will have an architectural stance. The houseboat alternate solution with the highest score based off the matrix will become the design I use to create my final solution from. The houseboat designs will be given a rating ranging from 1-4 for each category so that one can see which design solves the category the best and so on.
Houseboat Alternate Solution Matrix
|
Alternate Solution I
|
Alternate Solution II
|
Alternate Solution III
|
Alternate Solution IV
|
Living area for at least 2 people without taking up too much space
|
3
|
1
|
2
|
4
|
Rooms compressed yet have enough space for comfortable living
|
4
|
1
|
3
|
2
|
Aesthetics
|
3
|
4
|
2
|
1
|
Ship height should not exceed a safe height
|
4
|
4
|
4
|
4
|
Deck space
|
4
|
1
|
2
|
3
|
Houseboat should have a strong, safe exterior material
|
4
|
4
|
4
|
4
|
Houseboat must have appropriately dimensioned superstructure
|
4
|
4
|
4
|
4
|
House portion should not cover the entire surface of ship base
|
3
|
1
|
2
|
4
|
Follows all legal limitations set forth by the state of residency
|
4
|
4
|
4
|
4
|
Can withstand the harshest weather of the particular environment
|
4
|
4
|
4
|
4
|
Good flow between rooms
|
4
|
1
|
2
|
3
|
Strong material used for design
|
4
|
4
|
4
|
4
|
Final Score:
|
45
|
33
|
37
|
41
|
FInal Decision: Alternate Solution 1
With a score of 45 out of a possible 48, there is no question that the first alternate solution is an ideal design for the final solution to be based off of. The first solution incorporates everything the client required, followed the specifications and limitations set prior to design, and has features that sets it apart from the rest of the pack. Unique features, such as the guest room private balcony and lay out of the second floor game room, caused this design to be more desirable than the others. However, one of the best features of the houseboat can be seen when first entering the houseboat. When a person first steps foot on the houseboat, one is faced with two choices of entry: front door or side stairway. If the client was coming home or bringing a couple friends home, they could enter through the front double glass sliding doors into the living room. The side stairway, however, allows the client to bring home people she may not know as well for a party or game night and can bring the guests onto the second floor deck or into the game room without having to walk through the client’s home. This allows for the client to have more privacy and avoid the risk of strangers damaging or stealing her belongings. Also, the client’s privacy increases when viewing the layout of the master bedroom. The master bedroom has a pocket door to enclose it from the rest of the house. With this, the client can gain maximum privacy with the slide of a hidden door, or she can leave it open so that she could entertain guests on the stern deck of the houseboat. Also, the master bedroom has its own bathroom connected to a shower room shared by the whole house. This let’s the client have a private bathroom while still only having one shower so that she can save room and money by only having one shower. Along with the other designs, the first alternate solution has many large windows throughout the house and has a glass double sliding door for bow and stern entrances.
The only areas that the first solution failed to achieve the highest scores in were for aesthetics, living space, and space occupied by the house. In the aesthetics category, the first solution received a 3 rather than a 4 because the second solution gave the master bedroom a bedside lake view since it was located on the second floor unlike the first solution’s master bedroom. The first solution came in second for living space because the room on the first floor takes up too much space while only housing one person, for that reason, I will be revising that design flaw in the final solution. Finally, the reason the first solution did not achieve best for the category of not covering the entire space of the houseboat with an architectural structure was that the first solution’s stern deck was much smaller than the last solution’s deck because of the layout of the bathrooms. Despite not receiving a perfect score of 48, the first alternate solution received the closest possible score and incorporates every feature in which was desired by the client and followed the specifications and limitations of the houseboat.
















